YorkSEO Agency

Guide · Reviews and reputation

How to respond to a negative review

A bad review is not the problem. The reply is where the damage is done or undone, because every future customer reads it. Here is how to write one, and when a review can be taken down.

By the York SEO Agency teamUpdated 2 minute read

In short

  • Wait until you are calm, check the facts, and reply once.
  • Write for the next customer reading it, not to win the argument.
  • Never reveal personal details about the reviewer or their dealings with you.
  • Google removes reviews that break its policies, not reviews that are merely unfair.

Before you write anything

  1. Leave it for a few hours. Replies written in anger read as anger.
  2. Find out what happened. Speak to whoever dealt with the customer.
  3. Decide whether the complaint is fair, partly fair or mistaken.
  4. If you can put it right, try to do so directly first.

What a good reply does

  • Thanks the person for the feedback.
  • Acknowledges the problem without grovelling or arguing.
  • Says briefly what you have done or will do.
  • Offers a way to continue the conversation privately.
  • Stops there. One reply, a few sentences.

Examples to adapt

A fair complaint

“Thank you for telling us, and I am sorry we kept you waiting. That is not the service we want to give. I have spoken to the team about what went wrong on Saturday. If you would be willing to give us another chance, please ring me directly on the shop number.”

A complaint you disagree with

“Thank you for your feedback. I am sorry you were disappointed. Our records of the visit differ from your account, and I would welcome the chance to go through it with you. Please contact me at the office so we can look into it properly.”

Someone you cannot identify as a customer

“Thank you for your comment. We have no record of dealing with anyone by this name, and we would like to understand what happened. Please get in touch with us directly so that we can help.”

Confidentiality. Never confirm details of what someone bought, what was wrong or what was said. For clinics, solicitors and anyone else with a duty of confidentiality, do not even confirm the reviewer was a client.

When a review can be removed

Google removes reviews that break its policies. It does not remove reviews because the business disagrees with them. Grounds that can succeed:

  • The review is fake or part of a pattern of fake reviews.
  • It is about a different business.
  • It was written by a competitor or a former employee with an axe to grind.
  • It contains abuse, hate speech or personal information.
  • It is advertising or spam.

Report it from your Google Business Profile by flagging the review and choosing the reason. Google also provides a tool for checking the status of reports and appealing a refusal. Keep any evidence you have.

The best answer to a bad review

More good ones. A single poor review among fifty recent good ones reassures people that the reviews are real. The same review among three is a third of your reputation. Our guide to getting more Google reviews covers how.

Still have a question?

Ask it. A person will answer.

We reply by email during office hours.

We only use your details to reply to this enquiry. Privacy policy.

Straight answers

Questions people ask.

Something we have not covered? Ask us directly, a person will answer.

Can I delete a bad Google review?

No. Only the reviewer or Google can remove it. You can report it if it breaks Google’s policies, and you can reply.

Should I reply to every negative review?

Yes, once, calmly. Silence looks like indifference; an argument looks worse.

What if the reviewer was never a customer?

Say so politely in your reply, invite them to contact you, and report the review to Google as not reflecting a genuine experience.

Do negative reviews hurt my ranking?

One or two among many do little harm, and a mix looks genuine. A low overall rating, or no recent reviews, matters more.

Can I take legal action over a false review?

In serious cases a false and damaging statement may be defamatory, but that is a matter for a solicitor. Most are better handled with a calm reply and a report.

Next step

Worried about your reviews? Let a person look.

Send your business name. We will look at your reviews and replies, and tell you what a new customer sees, and what to do about it.

  1. 01You send the website and what you want search to do.
  2. 02A person inspects how you appear today, no automated score.
  3. 03You get the clearest opportunities, and an honest view on whether we are the right team.

No website yet? Type your business name instead.

A person reads every request. No automated score.

We only use your details to reply to this enquiry. Privacy policy.

Call Review my reputation