YorkSEO Agency

Guide · Websites and technical

Shopify vs WooCommerce: which should you choose?

Both can run a successful online shop, and both can rank well. They differ in who does the upkeep and how much freedom you have. Here is how to choose.

By the York SEO Agency teamUpdated 2 minute read

In short

  • Shopify is a hosted service: a monthly fee, and the technical upkeep is done for you.
  • WooCommerce is free software added to WordPress: more freedom, and the upkeep is yours.
  • For SEO, both are capable. Catalogue structure matters far more than the platform.
  • Choose on how you sell and who will run it, not on what is fashionable.

The difference in one table

ShopifyWooCommerce
What it isA hosted shop you rent by the month.Free, open-source software that adds a shop to a WordPress site.
CostsA subscription, plus apps and payment fees.Hosting, paid extensions and someone to maintain it.
EaseSimple to set up and hard to break.A steeper start; more to learn.
FlexibilityWorks within Shopify’s structure.Almost anything can be changed.
UpkeepSecurity, updates and hosting are handled for you.Updates, backups and security are your responsibility.
ContentAdequate pages and blog.WordPress is excellent for content.
SEOGood. Some address formats are fixed.Good. Full control, which needs using carefully.

Choose Shopify if

  • Selling products is the main purpose of the site.
  • Nobody in the business wants to look after software.
  • You want to be trading quickly.
  • You value reliability over fine control.

Choose WooCommerce if

  • You already have a WordPress site you are happy with.
  • Content matters as much as the shop: guides, articles, a large information site.
  • You need something Shopify’s structure does not allow.
  • You have someone, in-house or hired, to maintain it.

What about SEO?

Neither platform will rank a shop for you, and neither will stop you ranking. Shopify fixes parts of its page addresses and can create duplicate addresses for the same product; both are manageable. WooCommerce gives total control, which means more ways to get it wrong and a tendency to slow down as plugins are added.

What decides ecommerce rankings is whether there is a well-made category page for each way people search your range. That is the same job on either. See ecommerce SEO.

Changing your mind later

Shops move between platforms all the time. Products, customers and orders can be transferred. The risk is to search visibility, because every address changes, so a move needs a redirect plan like any other site migration.

Still have a question?

Ask it. A person will answer.

We reply by email during office hours.

We only use your details to reply to this enquiry. Privacy policy.

Straight answers

Questions people ask.

Something we have not covered? Ask us directly, a person will answer.

Which is better for SEO, Shopify or WooCommerce?

Neither has a decisive advantage. A well-structured shop ranks on both; a badly structured one struggles on both.

Which is cheaper?

It depends on what you add. Shopify’s costs are visible and monthly. WooCommerce looks cheaper at first, but hosting, extensions and maintenance add up.

Can I move from one to the other?

Yes. Plan the redirects carefully so rankings move with the shop.

What about Wix or Squarespace?

Fine for a small range and a simple shop. Larger catalogues outgrow them.

Which do you recommend?

Shopify for most shops where selling is the main job; WooCommerce where the business is already on WordPress or needs something unusual. We will say which and why.

Next step

Not sure which fits? Ask us.

Tell us what you sell and where you are now. We will recommend a platform, explain why and give you a clear quote if you want one.

  1. 01You send the website and what you want search to do.
  2. 02A person inspects how you appear today, no automated score.
  3. 03You get the clearest opportunities, and an honest view on whether we are the right team.

A person reads every request. No automated score.

We only use your details to reply to this enquiry. Privacy policy.

Call Get platform advice